Horror Writers Discuss the Scariest Tales They have Actually Encountered

A Renowned Horror Author

A Chilling Tale by a master of suspense

I encountered this story years ago and it has haunted me ever since. The so-called “summer people” turn out to be the Allisons from the city, who rent an identical isolated lakeside house annually. This time, rather than going back to urban life, they decide to lengthen their holiday for a month longer – a decision that to unsettle everyone in the surrounding community. Everyone conveys the same veiled caution that no one has remained by the water past the end of summer. Regardless, the Allisons insist to stay, and at that point things start to get increasingly weird. The individual who brings the kerosene refuses to sell to them. Nobody will deliver supplies to their home, and as the family attempt to go to the village, the automobile fails to start. A storm gathers, the power of their radio die, and as darkness falls, “the elderly couple clung to each other in their summer cottage and waited”. What might be the Allisons waiting for? What do the locals know? Each occasion I revisit the writer’s chilling and thought-provoking narrative, I’m reminded that the finest fright originates in the unspoken.

An Acclaimed Writer

An Eerie Story by Robert Aickman

In this brief tale two people go to an ordinary beach community in which chimes sound continuously, a perpetual pealing that is bothersome and puzzling. The first truly frightening scene takes place at night, when they choose to go for a stroll and they are unable to locate the water. The beach is there, the scent exists of decaying seafood and salt, surf is audible, but the ocean is a ghost, or a different entity and more dreadful. It is simply profoundly ominous and every time I go to a beach in the evening I recall this story that ruined the ocean after dark for me – in a good way.

The young couple – the woman is adolescent, the man is mature – return to the inn and discover why the bells ring, during a prolonged scene of enclosed spaces, macabre revelry and death-and-the-maiden meets grim ballet chaos. It’s an unnerving reflection about longing and decay, two people aging together as a couple, the bond and aggression and affection of marriage.

Not just the most frightening, but likely one of the best concise narratives available, and a personal favourite. I encountered it in the Spanish language, in the debut release of this author’s works to be published in Argentina several years back.

Catriona Ward

A Dark Novel by an esteemed writer

I perused this book by a pool overseas in 2020. Despite the sunshine I felt an icy feeling within me. I also experienced the electricity of excitement. I was writing a new project, and I had hit a wall. I wasn’t sure if there was an effective approach to write various frightening aspects the narrative involves. Experiencing this novel, I realized that there was a way.

Released decades ago, the novel is a dark flight into the thoughts of a young serial killer, the main character, inspired by a notorious figure, the serial killer who killed and mutilated 17 young men and boys in Milwaukee between 1978 and 1991. Notoriously, this person was obsessed with creating a compliant victim who would never leave him and attempted numerous macabre trials to accomplish it.

The acts the book depicts are terrible, but similarly terrifying is the mental realism. Quentin P’s dreadful, shattered existence is plainly told with concise language, details omitted. The audience is immersed trapped in his consciousness, obliged to see ideas and deeds that horrify. The foreignness of his thinking is like a tangible impact – or getting lost on a desolate planet. Going into this story is not just reading and more like a physical journey. You are swallowed whole.

An Accomplished Author

White Is for Witching by Helen Oyeyemi

During my youth, I sleepwalked and eventually began experiencing nightmares. Once, the terror featured a vision in which I was trapped within an enclosure and, upon awakening, I realized that I had torn off a piece out of the window frame, attempting to escape. That building was falling apart; when storms came the downstairs hall became inundated, insect eggs dropped from above into the bedroom, and at one time a large rat ascended the window coverings in that space.

Once a companion gave me Helen Oyeyemi’s novel, I had moved out at my family home, but the story of the house high on the Dover cliffs seemed recognizable to myself, longing at that time. It is a novel concerning a ghostly clamorous, emotional house and a female character who consumes chalk off the rocks. I cherished the story deeply and went back frequently to the story, consistently uncovering {something

Angela Frye
Angela Frye

Elara is a passionate writer and digital storyteller with a love for poetry and nature-inspired content.